Courtney Goudswaard
•
April 13, 2023

👀 TL;DR: Ought to I promote on Amazon? Even probably the most profitable Amazon sellers will admit it’s a love/hate relationship. Promoting on Amazon comes with its prices and difficulties, but additionally huge potential. So, is promoting on Amazon price it? In the event you have a look at the numbers alone — sure.

To Amazon or to not Amazon? It’s a call most entrepreneurs will face, and it’s not a straightforward one. You must consider a sophisticated record of potential alternatives in opposition to the myriad of challenges associated to promoting on-line.

In the event you’re looking for a easy reply, you then is likely to be tempted to purely have a look at the numbers. In line with the State of the Amazon Vendor 2023 report, 89% of Amazon sellers are worthwhile, and 37% reported elevated earnings in 2022 regardless of rising prices. However brief time period earnings are usually not the precise purpose for each enterprise. Corporations targeted on model constructing might wrestle with Amazon, which prioritizes the shopper expertise with out highlighting the businesses who provide widespread merchandise.

In line with our discussion board’s success tales, the hot button is to make use of the Amazon platform as a step in your organization’s journey. It really works greatest as a facilitator of development, both in the beginning levels of constructing a enterprise, or after a model has established buyer affinity.

The important thing recommendation is: Don’t solely depend on Amazon gross sales. Construct your enterprise exterior of the platform as nicely.

Amazon’s dominance within the eCommerce business is plain. Nonetheless, in line with our 2022 eCommerce Traits Report, the proportion of retailers promoting on Amazon has declined barely from 55.8% to 53%, indicating a turning level to be aware of.

Whereas current sellers aren’t planning to go away, off-Amazon manufacturers are outperforming their Amazon counterparts in most metrics. This development could sign a gradual decline in Amazon’s affect within the years to come back.

However take into account that Amazon is a power to be reckoned with, making $514 billion in annual income final yr. However numbers alone don’t inform the entire story.

Many manufacturers hesitate to promote on Amazon because of related charges, relinquishing buyer relationships, and worry of cannabilizing gross sales or model picture.

 This complete information goals to provide you a holistic image of what to think about when making this choice and provide recommendation from different entrepreneurs who’ve confronted the identical alternative.

We’ll cowl:

• Amazon Gross sales: Execs and Cons
• Prices to Promote on Amazon: What You Have to Know
• Mastering Amazon Gross sales: Insider Suggestions and Tips
• Selecting Worthwhile Merchandise to Promote on Amazon
• Go-To-Market Methods for Amazon
• Issues for Amazon Order Achievement
• Manufacturers’ Success Tales: Shifting On and Off the Amazon Platform

Weighing Up the Alternative Price + Blended Opinions

The state of play: If you’re Anti-Amazon, all the identical causes nonetheless exist, however it continues to get higher. Within the face of quickly rising prices and troublesome development, anybody that has been on the fence about attempting Amazon ought to strike now.

Founding father of Petalura.com Allan Shiffrin sparked an fascinating thread on EcommerceFuel’s (ECF) group discussion board earlier this yr.

Context: Petalura, a Shopify retailer reselling distinctive merchandise, grew to an 8-figure vendor in 2022. Dealing with challenges with extra stock and decreased money movement, they thought-about exploring Amazon as an choice to complement their efforts in 2023 with out a big upfront funding.

“Initially, the rationale I’ve been contemplating it is because of a big quantity of a specific product we provide. They’re packaged with Petalura branding and are distinctive, with restricted availability.”

The thread generated blended opinions in our group, reflecting the continuing debate about whether or not promoting on Amazon is price it.

Right here’s a recap: 

• One ECF member strongly means that Amazon just isn’t the precise platform for promoting distinctive merchandise as it’s best fitted to fast-moving commodities. Additionally it is a high-risk channel that requires lots of power.
• One other ECF member factors out that Amazon’s charges and commissions are fairly excessive, which might be difficult for resellers with low margins. Moreover, there could also be further promoting prices.
• An ECF member disagrees with the earlier opinions and believes that high-quality (distinctive) merchandise can promote nicely on Amazon, particularly if they’ve unique contracts with the producers to signify them on the platform.
• An ECF member who states they’re pro-Amazon, means that there are nice prospects for unique reselling and personal label objects on the platform. They counsel that it’s price attempting out a couple of SKUs to see what occurs and observe that unique partnerships with producers and types might be useful however could not at all times be possible because of low margins.
• One other member warns that promoting on Amazon is a long-term sport that requires funding in itemizing constructing, assessment technology, and promoting for a long-term ROI. Nonetheless, if performed proper, it could add vital income to the model.

Based mostly on these 5 opinions alone, what’s clear is there isn’t a one-size-fits-all reply to promoting on Amazon. Every opinion presents a special perspective and set of concerns.

So let’s break the decision-making course of down additional.

The Prices of Promoting on Amazon

The reply no one likes: it relies upon. The worth tag for promoting on Amazon is determined by a couple of components like what you’re promoting, how you propose to satisfy orders, and which promoting plan you select. However that’s truly an excellent factor! It means you possibly can combine and match choices to provide you with the proper plan that aligns together with your targets and finances.

 Learn extra on Amazon’s pricing web page.

 For a extra detailed breakdown of the required prices, really helpful prices, and additional prices—extremely suggest testing Jungle Scout’s detailed prices breakdown.

They divide the prices into three classes; required, really helpful, and bonus. For the sake of time, a TLDR model of this breakdown is beneath.

Overview: The plan is to promote a product on Amazon US as a personal label utilizing the Achievement by Amazon (FBA) mannequin. The full landed value of the merchandise is $4, and the intention is to get a 100% Return on Funding. The product will likely be customary dimension, gentle sufficient to ship by air, and 500 models will likely be bought on the market.

Word for the reader: It’s seemingly you have already got an thought of stock and pattern prices, however for the sake of offering a full image, we’ll embrace the additional element.

Required prices breakdown:

• Samples: $100 every (really helpful to order 3, so whole value round $300)
• Stock: $2,000 for 500 models ($4 per unit, together with delivery)
• Amazon Skilled Sellers Account: $39.99 monthly
• UPC: $30 for a GTIN/barcode from GS1

Contemplate stock value (the most important funding), Amazon Skilled Sellers Account charge, and $30 one-time UPC code value— all essential components affecting profitability.

 Whole required prices: $2,570

Beneficial Prices Breakdown:

Sponsored advert finances have to be used with optimized product listings for efficient conversion. Prior analysis is important to make sure trademark availability earlier than making a model. Early trademark registration permits Amazon Model Registry advantages.

 Whole really helpful prices: $650 (plus required prices)

Bonus Prices Breakdown

• Design work: $200
• Product images: $300

Success in promoting on Amazon requires good design and photographs. Rent a talented designer from Upwork or Fiverr for an expert emblem and packaging. Use white background and life-style pictures for higher product visibility. Closeups and comparisons can convey dimension and high quality. Skilled picture enhancing can value $25-$50 per picture.

 Whole bonus prices: $500 (plus required prices)

 The Grand Whole: It prices between $2790 and $3,940 to start out an Amazon enterprise.

Jungle Scout’s survey reveals Amazon sellers spend $3,836 to start out their companies. For personal label utilizing Amazon FBA, prices vary from $2,790 to $3,940, together with obligatory, really helpful ($650), and bonus prices ($500).

Takeaway: Whereas there are prices to promoting on Amazon, these prices are usually no totally different to what you’d incur with your personal Shopify retailer. Nonetheless, you may say there are “totally different” prices at play right here—and it actually is determined by what you’re ready to tackle as collateral.

Mastering Amazon Gross sales: Insider Suggestions & Tips You Want To Know Earlier than Beginning

No smoke and mirrors right here— solely actual, actionable recommendation from those that have been there, performed that. 

Able to make a take care of the satan? 😈

Regardless of the challenges, an ECF member admits it’s too exhausting to reside with out Amazon.

On prime of changing into reliant on Amazon for almost all of his gross sales, he provides to the record of Amazon vendor challenges;

• Lack of vendor help: Amazon’s customer support is predominantly automated (run by bots), which suggests it may be difficult to talk with a human consultant who can help you together with your drawback.
• Issues created by bots: The bots create issues with key phrase matching.
  • For instance, the vendor who makes a speciality of stickers has encountered points when trying to promote designs that function the phrase “use hand sanitizer” on Amazon. The platform’s automated system rejects the stickers, as Amazon requires sellers to hunt approval earlier than promoting hand sanitizer. Regardless of opening a case and explaining that the merchandise are stickers, the vendor has confronted repeated rejection from Amazon.
• Sluggish resolutions: Amazon will lose your FBA objects and require you to show that you just personal the misplaced product.
  • On this case, the vendor is the producer to allow them to solely ship uncooked materials invoices. They’ve misplaced about $1,400 price of our merchandise, and nonetheless ready on Amazon’s choice weeks later.

Whereas Amazon makes it tougher with minimal help and creating points you have to resolve, one other ECF member mentioned they’ve a staff of 4 totally different consultants to work throughout their model and purchasers’ Amazon accounts. 

• Model supervisor— drives technique
• Promoting specialist—is aware of adverts in and out
• Content material creator—designs the listings (photoshop, and many others.)
• Compliance specialist—makes use of our SOPs to combat with Vendor Assist and get reimbursements

On that observe, promoting is totally required to succeed. With one search on Amazon you possibly can see that 90% of merchandise above-the-fold are adverts. It is a professional and con. In the event you do promoting nicely you possibly can rise above your rivals. However for those who don’t, you’ll be placing your product discoverability and conversion charges in danger.

However the query nonetheless stays, goes down this path price it?

Checking Search Demand: An Alternative Hiding in Plain Sight 

Do you know you may be producing demand on Amazon as a by-product of your present advertising? Curiously, 66% of customers begin their on-line purchasing with searches for merchandise on Amazon.

Need to know if there’s a chance in your model? Right here’s how:

• Analysis demand on Amazon: Sort in your key phrases into the Amazon search bar. This gives you an thought of what individuals are looking for when they’re on the lookout for merchandise much like yours on Amazon.
• Use Merchantwords (or related database) to get estimates of search volumes: This may offer you widespread searches associated to your model and their estimated search volumes.
• Examine for rivals bidding in your model identify: Be careful for any rivals who is likely to be bidding in your model identify and taking away your potential prospects.
• Use Helium10 or JungleScout to seek out product alternatives: As a substitute of specializing in the merchandise that you’ve good stock in, these instruments may help you discover the merchandise which have probably the most alternative for development on Amazon.

An instance for Petalura:

These are the most typical searches. Subsequent, search on MerchantWords for Petalura to see widespread searches and their search quantity.

From this preliminary investigation, you’ll not solely be capable to see if individuals are looking on Amazon for you, but when different manufacturers are taking prospects away from you by bidding on key phrases that include your identify.

There’s an argument to say that for those who don’t promote on Amazon, another person will. 

However it’s not about going all-in. The secret’s figuring out what merchandise to promote to satisfy the demand. 

Selecting the Most Worthwhile Merchandise To Promote: Branded vs. Generic 📦

Do you have to promote your personal branded merchandise solely on Amazon or generic non-branded objects too? Which ends up in higher gross sales? Let’s discuss profitable methods utilized by different ECF members.

Promoting non-exclusive SKUs

One ECF member began promoting on Amazon round 11 years in the past. He listed his merchandise on the market on Amazon by matching them with current ASINs (Amazon Customary Identification Quantity) of comparable merchandise already listed on Amazon. This technique allowed him to piggyback off the present demand and site visitors for these merchandise with out having to create a singular product itemizing from scratch. By doing so, promoting on Amazon was price it, as he might learn the way the Amazon platform labored and generate further income and revenue margins with minimal effort.

From his perspective, having good gross sales on Amazon for non-branded merchandise is feasible—however you shouldn’t make it your major enterprise mannequin.

I’d say out of the 10-15 or so of these merchandise over the previous 5 years, 50% of them have been very profitable for a short while (1 yr or much less), 20% have been full let-downs, and 20-30% are nonetheless promoting on Amazon (US) very sturdy.

ECF Member

His recommendation for itemizing non-branded merchandise: Photos and titles are essential for product listings, and setting your product other than rivals could make a distinction. However, select your product fastidiously, as your account’s maturity and monitor report can also affect product rankings.

🔥 Sizzling tip: Use an Amazon itemizing optimization device like Helium10 that will help you enhance each side of your product itemizing to maximise gross sales and increase your rankings.

He talked about that regardless of promoting generic merchandise, they record them underneath their very own model identify to make the most of the advantages of Model Registry and forestall others from becoming a member of the itemizing.

Learn extra: Instance in case you are promoting non-exclusive SKUs (for current ECF members)

Itemizing older merchandise

Isaac Medeiros Founding father of Mini Katana determined to promote merchandise on Amazon after 2 years of resistance—after he came upon they’d 100k branded searches a month on Amazon. His technique is itemizing older merchandise and saving one of the best stuff for his personal web site.

We’re solely placing older merchandise on Amazon and protecting the actually great things on our web site. Thus far, it’s set to do 7 figures this yr with minimal effort from my staff (the advertising will get performed with or with out Amazon).

ECF Member & Founding father of Mini Katana Isaac Medeiros

Reader Word: Isaac lately mentioned they stopped promoting on Amazon because it wasn’t price it. It was an experiment that didn’t work out nicely for them ultimately—primarily as a result of they do drops, and that technique didn’t translate nicely on the platform.

Provide restricted sizes and colours

One other ECF member mentioned he presents a restricted providing of sizes and colours on Amazon—which could possibly be one other good technique to think about when you have lots of SKUs.

Promoting high-end enterprise merchandise

This ECF member recommends branding merchandise for higher management and alternatives within the gross sales course of. Nonetheless, there are nonetheless some alternatives in promoting open-branded merchandise, however it comes with potential dangers and volatility.

My private expertise is that there are some alternatives in open-branded merchandise however you need to strive branding the place attainable when attainable.

ECF Member

✅ Key takeaways:

• Good gross sales are attainable for non-branded merchandise, however it shouldn’t be the principle enterprise mannequin.
• Itemizing in opposition to current ASINs can earn income and assist be taught the nuances of the platform.
• Photos and titles are very important for non-branded product listings, together with product differentiation.
• Account maturity and monitor report could affect product rating.
• Promote older merchandise on Amazon whereas saving greatest ones in your web site.
• Providing a restricted vary of sizes/colours on Amazon might work when you have many SKUs.
• Aggressive pricing is essential with out model differentiation to attain an excellent rating.
• The worth needs to be at or beneath the highest listings to have an opportunity at rating.

Amazon Go-to-Market Strategies 🏌️

Two finish methods for home Amazon sellers: fats margin and dominate adverts, or let-it-ride. The previous entails elevating costs, rebranding, and specializing in adverts.

The latter entails shutting off adverts completely, with one massive caveat: the general public having success with this have a robust model presence exterior of Amazon, an already dominant product, or a particularly distinctive product that can not be simply replicated.

Amazon Order Achievement Issues 🚚

Most entrepreneurs start promoting merchandise on Amazon by creating a personal label product and utilizing Amazon FBA, which 86% of sellers favor. In comparison with 37% preferring FBM (Achievement by Service provider). And based mostly on some ECF members experiences, FBA is healthier for gross sales.

FBA will double your gross sales based mostly on what we’ve seen through the years.

ECF Member

One other ECF member solely makes use of FBM because of their giant variety of SKUs, though they lately launched some FBA productsm which already signify ~5% of their Amazon gross sales. 

✅ Some key factors:

• Non-public label sellers favor FBA, whereas dropshippers and handmade artisans favor FBM.
• FBA sellers usually spend extra upfront on stock funding.
• FBA permits for absolutely distant ecommerce companies.
• FBM sellers can begin promoting quicker than FBA sellers.
• FBM sellers often have bigger product catalogs than FBA sellers.
• 22% of FBM sellers use a mixture of FBM and FBA.

However from buyer scams to A-Z claims, there’s a irritating aspect to promoting on Amazon—irrespective of which success methodology you select.

After promoting on Amazon for a few years, this vendor shares his rising frustration with promoting on Amazon, citing buyer scams and A-Z claims as widespread complications. 

• In a single occasion, a buyer returned a $250 FBA merchandise with an older, broken model of the product and one other vendor’s sticker on it, however his declare was unsuccessful. 
• In one other case, USPS misplaced a seller-fulfilled merchandise, prompting an A-Z declare from the customer. Though he shortly resolved the problem by refunding and sending a brand new merchandise, Amazon nonetheless marked his account negatively.

To deliver you out of the rabbit gap of success experiences, bear in mind this: Scams and claims can nonetheless happen, no matter whether or not you select FBA or FBM. It’s necessary to weigh the professionals and cons of every choice and select the one which aligns together with your targets and wishes. Keep knowledgeable about potential dangers and issues that will come up whereas promoting on Amazon.

It’s Not One or the Different: Retaining Your Eggs in A number of Baskets ⚖️

SMB sellers utilizing a multichannel technique for on-line gross sales are growing and anticipated to proceed in 2023. 61% of Amazon SMB sellers offered on a minimum of one different channel in 2022, up from 58% within the earlier yr. 

An ECF member thought-about pivoting to Amazon by shutting down his Shopify retailer, however obtained recommendation from discussion board members in opposition to it.

Context: He proposed a method to simplify and scale his enterprise by shutting down his Shopify retailer and shifting all weblog content material to his WP web site. He deliberate to ship merchandise on to Amazon FBA, use e-mail advertising and their WP web site to extend site visitors and gross sales on Amazon, and ahead the model URL to the Amazon retailer. He additionally deliberate to promote on a number of on-line marketplaces and create a store web page on their WP weblog to hyperlink to every market, believing this could get rid of the issue of consumers getting info from their web site however shopping for merchandise from Amazon and allow them to outmaneuver Chinese language rivals.

As a substitute: You need a numerous enterprise technique and never be too leveraged to Amazon.

Do Amazon and your Shopify retailer. Do Amazon to pay the payments and scale. Then use that Amazon cash to construct a model off Amazon.

ECF Member

You need to be testing issues. Take a look at sending stock into FBA, check vendor fulfilled. Take a look at purchase with Prime. Take a look at all of it and see what’s the cost-benefit.

ECF Member

However others have chosen to remain off.

I’ve chosen to remain off Amazon for these causes: I need to personal my buyer knowledge, I need management over the shopper expertise, and returns and opinions are in my management.

ECF Member

Success Tales: Journeys Into And/Or Out Of Amazon 🚀

Listed here are some manufacturers which have skilled success by both coming into or leaving the Amazon platform. 

Tarriss Journey Gear—Moved away from Amazon

Tarriss Journey Gear began on Amazon in 2014 with a $6,000 funding and a single personal label product. In 4 years, they reached seven figures, with 90% of gross sales coming from Amazon. However in 2018, they determined to diversify and transfer away from Amazon.

We’ve lastly kicked the Amazon behavior like we’ve been attempting to do for years now. Amazon accounted for lower than 20% of our income. At the moment, it accounts for 0%. Simply this morning we closed a deal to promote Tarriss Journey Gear finishing our journey into and out of Amazon.

TouchUpDirect—Adjusted their Amazon reliance

TouchUpDirect initially targeted on Amazon, however they later diversified their gross sales channels. They presently have a 75/25 break up between their web site and Amazon, with a method in place to develop their Amazon enterprise whereas defending their eCommerce enterprise, corresponding to solely providing their prime colours on Amazon. They’ve had success with FBM and plan to interchange all FBM gross sales with FBA sooner or later.

Animalhouse Health—Branching Out to Amazon & Retaining Shopify Retailer

ECF member Paul Jackson, founding father of Animalhouse Health, solely offered on Shopify for 2 years. Lately, they determined to launch on Amazon to succeed in new prospects with out affecting their DTC gross sales. Their most important product MonkeyFeet already has some search quantity and copycat variations on the eCommerce platform—so their supreme purpose is to rise above these rivals. Nonetheless, they’re nonetheless within the technique of launching on Amazon and haven’t evaluated its worthiness but.

Paul shared some perception into what he realized lately from eCommerceFuel Dwell: 

• Doing FBA as an alternative of simply FBM utilizing our current 3PL. Apparently, FBA converts 2-4x in addition to FBM, which is tough to cross up!
• Working some primary PPC adverts as a way to seize branded site visitors. We haven’t dove into this fairly but, however that is on the agenda.

If you’re pondering whether or not to chunk the Amazon bullet, AnimalHouse Health’ journey is one to look at!

Remaining Ideas: Is Promoting On Amazon Price It?

There’s no single definitive reply as to if promoting on Amazon is price it. It’s pure to really feel protecting of your model, so as an alternative of going all-in, strive dipping your toes with one or two merchandise to see the way it goes. You by no means know till you strive.

Need extra? Entry Almost 3,000 Amazon-Particular Discussions Inside ECF

If you’d like extra sources and recommendation from different entrepreneurs in your sneakers, be part of our group of 7-8-figure model on-line retailer house owners. All our members are vetted practitioners—not distributors or newcomers—making certain everybody has a deep, significant eCommerce expertise to share. Apply in the present day!

Put up by Courtney Goudswaard

Courtney Goudswaard is a contract author for eCommerce and associated SaaS manufacturers. She approaches her craft in a journalistic setting, delivering evidence-backed, action-packed, and easy-to-understand content material that retains your readers hooked. Join together with her through www.scribblecontent.com or on Twitter @courtig