The 2009 movie The Blind Aspect tells the story of a white household on a heartfelt mission: to save lots of the lifetime of “Massive Mike,” an unhoused Black 17-year-old who attends the native faculty with their son in Memphis, Tennessee.

As many critics would later observe, the story was a traditional “white savior” story that served to reward the goodness of white folks and erase the nuances of a Black child’s story of resilience. However audiences on the time heralded The Blind Aspect, which was primarily based on a e book of the identical title, as a tearjerker and the blueprint for a feel-good traditional. Plus, it was all a real story, primarily based on the actual occasions within the lifetime of Sean and Leigh Anne Tuohy and Michael Oher, who went on to play eight seasons within the NFL.

The movie earned greater than $300 million on the field workplace and was nominated for the Finest Image Oscar, whereas Sandra Bullock took house the Oscar for Finest Actress for her portrayal of household matriarch Leigh Anne Tuohy.

Now, nonetheless, Oher, a former NFL participant, has alleged that the crux of the story — {that a} white household adopted him out of homelessness — is a lie and that the household exploited his title and story for years to counterpoint themselves. Oher says that he believed he was a authorized member of the Tuohy household for practically twenty years, solely to study this yr that he was not.

Based on ESPN, Oher filed a 14-page petition in Tennessee’s Shelby County on Monday, alleging that Sean and Leigh Anne Tuohy by no means truly adopted him. As an alternative, the petition alleges, they tricked him right into a conservatorship, a authorized settlement that gave them authorized authority to make use of his title in enterprise offers, lower than three months after he turned 18. The petition claims that the household used Oher, now 37, to make thousands and thousands of {dollars} from the favored e book and 2009 blockbuster movie. He’s now asking that the probate courtroom finish the conservatorship and bar the household from utilizing Oher’s title and likeness. The petition additionally requests that the courtroom search an accounting of all the cash the Tuohys have made since beginning the conservatorship in 2004 and to pay Oher his share of the earnings, along with damages.

The information has confirmed surprising to those that continued to carry the film in excessive regard. Sean Tuohy instructed the Every day Memphian that he was “devastated” to listen to about Oher’s lawsuit and that it was “upsetting to suppose we might generate income off any of our kids.” Sean “SJ” Tuohy, the Tuohys’ organic son, in the meantime, mentioned that Oher was conscious of the conservatorship earlier than this yr. He additionally denied making thousands and thousands off the movie, telling the hosts of Barstool Radio that he’s obtained an extra $60,000 to $70,000 “over the course of the previous couple of years.” He added, “You’ll by no means hear me say something unhealthy about Michael Oher in any capability apart from I’m upset that he feels the best way that he does.”

On Tuesday, the household launched an announcement by their lawyer, Hollywood authorized “bulldog” Marty Singer, who can also be representing Lizzo and has represented Invoice Cosby. The household alleges that Oher demanded $15 million from them, in accordance with TMZ. In the event that they refused to pay it, the assertion says, Oher threatened that he would “plant a unfavourable story about them within the press.” The assertion additionally claims that the Tuohys have all the time been “upfront about how a conservatorship (from which not one penny was obtained) was established to help with Mr. Oher’s wants,” together with getting medical insurance. The household additional alleges that this isn’t the primary time that Oher has “tried to run this play.”

Even because the case turns into extra difficult by the minute, it’s resurfacing many present controversies round The Blind Aspect, notably the way it portrayed Oher as unintelligent and fully reliant on the Tuohys, and the way it capitalized on viewers’ consolation with white charity and Black struggling. Now, many are declaring how this new twist has validated longtime uneasiness with the movie, exhibiting that the white savior trope stays pervasive and obscures truths about exploitation.

The “chagrin and embarrassment” of Michael Oher’s conservatorship

Because the movie depicts it, Michael was homeless, ripped away from his drug-addicted mom when he was 7, and navigating the grueling foster system. The Tuohys, to the shock of Leigh Anne’s elite circle of mates, take Michael in and finally undertake him. However most of all, they encourage him to play soccer, setting him up for a profession within the NFL.

Oher grew to become an all-American left deal with and, later, a first-round draft choose by the Baltimore Ravens. He helped the Ravens win the Tremendous Bowl in 2013, with Leigh Anne and her daughter Collins sometimes watching from the sidelines, then signed a $20 million, multi-year take care of the Tennessee Titans in 2014. He was launched as a result of a toe harm earlier than enjoying for the Carolina Panthers till 2017. Oher’s profession finally earned him $34 million.

Based on Oher’s petition, the star soccer participant solely realized the reality of his relationship with the Tuohys this yr.

“Michael Oher found this mislead his chagrin and embarrassment in February of 2023, when he realized that the Conservatorship to which he consented on the idea that doing so would make him a member of the Tuohy household, in reality supplied him no familial relationship with the Tuohys,” the petition states. The petition additionally revealed that the conservatorship continues to at the present time, and amongst Oher’s requests is that the Tennessee courtroom terminates it.

In the meantime, over the many years, the Tuohys have continued to name Oher their adopted son, utilizing the alleged lie to spice up their basis and different promotional work.

WireImage

A conservatorship is a authorized association that cedes an individual’s private, monetary, and authorized decision-making powers to different folks. It’s supposed to assist people who can’t look after themselves as a result of well being issues, similar to a mind harm or psychological well being circumstances; the preparations have been within the cultural dialog with high-profile instances like these of Britney Spears and Amanda Bynes.

Conservatorships can get ugly, notably once they’re undesirable and when somebody isn’t even conscious that they’re a part of such an settlement. They can be utilized to disenfranchise and abuse folks with disabilities, permitting conservators to take near-full management of life choices, from the place the person lives to what they spend cash on.

“You’re entitled as an grownup to make choices about your funds and your property and your medical care. However all states have legal guidelines that acknowledge that some folks have diminished decision-making capability,” Josephine Gittler, a regulation professor and the creator of Reforming the Guardianship and Conservatorship System: An Introduction, instructed Vox’s Constance Grady. In Tennessee, the place the Tuohy conservatorship was organized, courts could switch “duties” from “an individual with a incapacity” who doesn’t have the flexibility to make sure choices to a conservator.

Oher, nonetheless, alleges that the Tuohys had him signal papers to enter right into a conservatorship regardless of him having no bodily or psychological disabilities rendering him incapable of taking good care of his personal issues. Whereas he believed the papers made him a authorized member of the Tuohy household, underneath the Tuohy conservatorship, he doesn’t have the ability to handle his monetary affairs.

Sean Tuohy has defended the conservatorship, arguing that it was initially created to permit Oher to play soccer on the College of Mississippi, however mentioned that he could be prepared to finish the conservatorship as soon as and for all.

The authorized submitting additionally states that Oher unknowingly signed away the rights to his life story to twentieth Century Fox in 2007 when he was 16, in accordance with the New York Instances. Within the petition, Oher acknowledged that he doesn’t bear in mind signing the contract and that if he did signal it, nobody defined it to him.

Sean Tuohy has mentioned that everybody in his household earned about $14,000 every from the film, whereas ESPN has reported that the Tuohys and their two delivery kids every made $225,000, along with 2.5 p.c of the movie’s “outlined web proceeds.”

Including to the confusion this week, creator and journalist Michael Lewis, who wrote the e book The Blind Aspect: Evolution of a Sport, on which the movie relies, instructed the Washington Publish that nobody concerned within the e book earned thousands and thousands from the film. “It’s outrageous how Hollywood accounting works, however the cash isn’t within the Tuohys’ pockets,” Lewis mentioned. By his accounting, twentieth Century Fox paid $250,000 for the choice to make the movie, which he divided 50-50 with the Tuohy household. The studio finally didn’t make the film; a smaller manufacturing firm finally produced The Blind Aspect, for which Lewis mentioned he and the Tuohy household have been then paid about $350,000 every. Lewis mentioned Oher started declining his royalty checks and that he believed the Tuohys started depositing royalty checks in a belief for Oher’s son.

The numerous controversies round The Blind Aspect

Lewis printed The Blind Aspect in 2006. Based on the petition, the Tuohys negotiated a film deal for the story chronicled within the e book shortly after the e book’s launch. It’s unclear whether or not Oher ever negotiated a life rights settlement with the Tuohys forward of the publication of the e book or movie.

The Blind Aspect movie obtained blended critiques and likewise quickly discovered itself on the middle of controversy. Critics argued that the portrayal of Oher performed into Uncle Tom stereotypes about Black folks as submissive to white authority. Many additionally took problem with the movie’s portrayal of the Tuohys as white saviors whose private charity helped an impoverished Black youth overcome challenges and discover his footing and potential.

In the meantime, Oher wrote in his memoir, I Beat the Odds: From Homelessness to the Blind Aspect and Past, the movie portrayed him as “dumb” as a substitute of as a child “who had by no means had constant educational instruction.”

Jason Merritt/Getty Photographs

Oher has publicly mentioned that the movie negatively impacted his profession. In 2015, he instructed ESPN that individuals make assumptions about him primarily based on how he was poorly portrayed within the movie. “Individuals have a look at me, they usually take issues away from me due to a film,” Oher mentioned. “They don’t actually see the talents and the sort of participant I’m. That’s why I get downgraded a lot, due to one thing off the sphere … That’s why I don’t like that film.’’

He additionally mentioned the movie introduced him an excessive amount of consideration when he simply wished to fly underneath the radar as an offensive lineman and that it incorrectly portrayed him as a child who didn’t perceive soccer. Oher wrote in his memoir, “Whether or not it was S.J. transferring round ketchup bottles or Leigh Anne explaining to me what blocking is about, I watched these scenes considering, ‘No, that’s not me in any respect! I’ve been learning — actually learning — the sport since I used to be a child!’”

Oher did, nonetheless, see some positives within the movie, notably its message about perseverance and in the way it portrayed the Tuohy household. “They’re my household and with out them I wouldn’t be right here,” he mentioned in 2016. “They taught me plenty of issues, confirmed me plenty of various things. It exhibits that for those who assist any individual and provides any individual an opportunity and don’t choose folks, look the place they’ll get to.”

It’s that belief and respect that he held for the Tuohys that has made the information of the continuing conservatorship all of the extra surprising and painful. And it’s the white savior trope that will have allowed the Tuohys to make use of their assumed benevolence to maneuver by the world unchecked.

As sociologist Matthew Hughey recounts in his e book The White Savior Movie, the white savior trope derives from outdated concepts similar to “manifest future” (the concept white settlers in America have been destined and ordained to increase westward and domesticate America), and the “White man’s burden” (the obligation of white colonizers to handle the affairs of these whom they colonize) — beliefs that motivated white folks to save lots of the “dysfunctional and darkish ‘different.’”

In Display Saviors: Hollywood Fictions of Whiteness, Hernán Vera and Andrew Gordon clarify that white savior narratives typically function a white determine who “saves blacks from slavery or oppression, rescues folks of shade from poverty or illness, or leads Indians in battle for his or her dignity and survival.”

Examples abound, from the 1990 western Dances With Wolves to the 2000 urban-set movie Discovering Forrester to 2011’s The Assist. In these motion pictures, white paternalism is portrayed as vital to raised American society and save folks of shade from themselves. The trope erases and romanticizes racism, and raises questions in regards to the harmful energy white persons are capable of wield once they’re seen as saviors. Many of those movies, like The Blind Aspect, have confronted their very own reckonings.

The tropes don’t simply exist on the web page or on the massive display. They occur in actual life; as NPR famous in 2011, with the movie’s success, the Tuohy household was “elevated to close sainthood.” Oher’s petition and the general public outcry over his conservatorship are difficult that picture.

For his half, Oher has tried to make peace with the Hollywood storyline of The Blind Aspect by recognizing the movie’s constructive impression and his position within the narrative. In 2015, he instructed the AP, “You’d be shocked what number of letters I’ve gotten, folks have adopted children or what number of lives have modified. I’m positively enthusiastic about that as a result of coming from poverty within the inside metropolis the place I come from, so many individuals look as much as me. They are saying ‘if I can do it, they’ll do it.’”

Replace, August 17, 10 am ET: This story was initially printed on August 15 and has been up to date most not too long ago to incorporate The Blind Aspect: Evolution of a Sport creator Michael Lewis’s response to the case.